Antique Meat
Gov't Struggles To Put Genie Back In Bottle
By Debbie Maimon, Yated
Government concern over growing support for Sholom Rubashkin among prominent advocacy groups have prompted efforts to suppress three amicus curiae briefs that call for a new trial.
The move betrays an effort "to shut the door" on mounting indications of questionable conduct in the case, Iowa ACLU's Randall Wilson said in a phone interview with Yated.
"What this shows is that a tender, raw nerve has been struck. It's very threatening to the Attorney's Office that Rubashkin's defense is gaining a surge of credibility from outside organizations that carry clout."
A written motion filed by the government last week asked the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals to reject the amicus curiae briefs because they present "no new arguments" that had not been covered in the appeal filed by Sholom Mordechai's attorneys.
The move has stunned legal experts. ACLU's Wilson said he has never encountered a case where the government refused to agree to the filing of an amicus curiae from the ACLU. Other experts consulted by this writer say they can find no precedent for the Department of Justice opposing a friend-of-the-court brief from any respected legal organization.
"Assuming for the sake of argument that the briefs present nothing new, they surely can't do any harm in that case. So why go to these unusual lengths to resist them?" asked the ACLU director.
He noted that something more serious is obviously at play. "This is an effort to keep at bay issues that might discredit some important people. They're trying to put the genie back in the bottle. But we're hoping to do just the opposite—we know there is more to discover and we need to bring that information out."
Advocacy Groups Tear Aside Veneer Of Legality
Joining the ACLU, two prominent legal and advocacy groups, WLF (Washington Legal Foundation) and NACDL (National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers) threw their support behind the appeal.
The WLF tore apart the veneer of legality masking Judge Reade's legal opinions, sacked her sentencing calculations, and accused her of violating the Federal Sentencing Guidelines. Representing 18 prominent law professors, former federal judges and former prosecutors, the WLF urged that the case be remanded to a different judge for re-sentencing.
The ACLU highlighted Judge Reade's active participation with prosecutors before the raid on Agriprocessors, which included e-mails in which Reade asked for a "final game plan" for the raid and a "briefing" on the operation. The brief accused her of violating the Constitution's Separation of Powers Doctrine by acting as an arm of the prosecution.
The organizations called on the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals to vacate Sholom Mordechai's conviction and grant him a new trial. "Due process demands it. The Constitution demands it," the ACLU insisted.
The NACDL brief was uncompromising and scathing in its criticism. It condemned ethical misconduct by Judge Reade and the federal prosecutors who oversaw the raid and the criminal prosecutions that followed. The brief said that the ICE documents support the claim that the Chief Judge was prejudiced in favor of the Government and thus must disqualify herself.
"She should not have discussed strategies and the ongoing investigation and other issues with prosecutors," the NACDL brief said. It noted that Reade repeatedly violated Constitutional mandates by attending the meetings at which these discussions were held and afterwards presiding at the trial.
Judge Reade's Charade
Reade compounded this wrongful conduct by concealing it from the defense, the brief asserted. Even worse, when confronted by disclosures of her behavior in the ICE documents in Sholom Mordechai's new-trial motion, Reade sweepingly dismissed the allegations as untrue.
She was obligated by law to turn the case over to an impartial judge as requested, but refused to do so. Instead, she accorded her own denials of wrongdoing the status of "facts," even though they contradicted assertions in the ICE documents.
She thus became the key "factual witness" in the case and used her own testimony about what she did or didn't do to arrive at a ruling in favor of herself.
The NACDL brief harshly criticized this charade. It called attention to Reade's clear violation of ethical and legal guidelines in her repeated denials of wrongdoing and in insisting her behavior was above reproach.
The NACDL brief so thoroughly demolished Judge Reade's credibility that it triggered a desperate attempt by the Attorney's Office to neutralize its impact by impugning the organization's integrity.
Gov't Effort To Quell Support For Rubashkin
In its motion to quell support for Sholom Mordechai, the government took aim at both NACDL and defense lawyers by insinuating that NACDL consulted with the defense team and made use of their help in writing the amicus curiae brief.
"Counsel for defendant appears to have had some involvement in the preparation of at least one of the briefs," the prosecutors complained. In the case of the NACDL brief, the appellate counsel appeared "to have done some editing and made some small suggestions," leaving the government no option but to object to the brief, the motion said.
Since there is nothing improper about defense counsel reviewing and making suggestions for an amicus brief, the prosecutors realized they were on shaky ground here. Reduced to an almost pathetic last-resort defense, they argue that if NACDL's arguments had sufficient merit they would have been advanced by "the defendant's cadre of attorneys."
Since they were not included in the defendant's appeal, it's obvious that they are "devoid of merit" and are nothing but a waste of everyone's time.
In other words, since the "cadre of attorneys" working for Sholom Mordechai are such powerhouses, they doubtlessly thought of every possible angle. Any argument not included in the appeal is therefore worthless.
How flattering to the appellate team that the government regards them as brilliant and infallible. But how self-contradictory and comical to propose trashing an amicus brief for possessing the key credential that the government earlier insisted such a brief must present—a new argument!
As all parties await the decision from the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals to accept or deny the amicus curiae briefs, the government's effort to put the genie back in the bottle is having the opposite effect.
"Rubashkin was fighting a very lonely battle. But the case has shifted and is now receiving increasing attention and support," one of his attorneys said.
"Prominent legal advocacy groups see this as a test case with broad implications for many other defendants in similar situations. There are countless people in this country who like Sholom Rubashkin have fallen victim to judicial or prosecutorial conduct, an antiquated sentencing system and an increasingly over-criminalized society."
About the Author
Antique IBM Dayton Meat Slicer
 |
 Antique McCray Refrigerator Co 8 Butcher Meat Cleaver Blacksmith Forged Steel $399.00 Time Remaining: 2d 21h 51m Buy It Now for only: $399.00 Buy It Now |
 Vtg Antique Hand Ground Solingen Germany Rare Pig Face Farmhouse Meat Cleaver $21.49 (7 Bids) Time Remaining: 1d 4h 3m |
 Foster Brothers Antique Meat Cleaver free shipping $27.01 (3 Bids) Time Remaining: 2d 4h 1m |
 Antique Wallace Silverplate Cold Meat Serving Fork my12 005 $14.99 Time Remaining: 29d 22h 12m Buy It Now for only: $14.99 Buy It Now |
 VINTAGE CAST IRON KEEN KUTTER MEAT GRINDER MOD KK 23 PAT 1906 SIMMONS KITCHEN $13.97 Time Remaining: 1h 18m |
 LARKIN Vintage Antique Meat Grinder Chopper 4 Blades Clamps to Table $9.99 Time Remaining: 6d 18h 44m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 Buy It Now |
 ANTIQUE VINTAGE 115 LONG FILET MEAT BREAD KNIFE WOOD HANDLE SILVER KNOBS $6.99 Time Remaining: 2h 21m |
 Rare Antique A J Deer CoRoyal Meat Slicing Machine Berkel $1,200.00 Time Remaining: 2h 7m |
 Antique Benedict MFR Co Silverplate Cold Meat Serving Fork my12 006 $14.99 Time Remaining: 29d 22h 12m Buy It Now for only: $14.99 Buy It Now |
 Antique 1911 Plymouth Gorham Sterling Silver Cold Meat Serving Fork $70.00 Time Remaining: 48m Buy It Now for only: $77.00 Buy It Now |
 ANTIQUE MEAT CLEAVER $149.00 Time Remaining: 17d 5h 9m Buy It Now for only: $149.00 Buy It Now |
 A 1907 ROLLMAN MEAT FOOD CHOPPER KITCHEN APPLIANCE AD $21.95 Time Remaining: 1h 55m |
 Very large antique hand forged meat cleaver $45.00 Time Remaining: 1d 4h 18m Buy It Now for only: $60.00 Buy It Now |
 VINTAGE UNIVERSAL 1 KITCHEN ANTIQUE MEAT GRINDER NEW BRITAIN CONN $12.00 Time Remaining: 27d 21h 38m Buy It Now for only: $12.00 Buy It Now |
 OLD ANTIQUE MEAT CHOPPER $9.99 Time Remaining: 3h 7m |
 Barn find Antique The American Slicing Machine 40902 Hand Crank Meat Slicer $350.00 Time Remaining: 6d 21h 49m Buy It Now for only: $350.00 Buy It Now |
 Antique Collectible 8 Farm Meat Fish Barn Scale 34177 Dated 1892 Brass Face $9.99 Time Remaining: 1h 31m |
 American Meat Institute Chart Thrifty Meat Cuts Food 1941 Antique Advertisement $5.99 Time Remaining: 29d 19h 28m Buy It Now for only: $5.99 Buy It Now |
 A 1943 HORMEL SPAM MEAT MEAL FOOD AUSTIN DINNER COOK HAM $21.95 Time Remaining: 4h 32m |
 Antique Vintage Rogers 1881 Casserole Spoon and Meat Fork Silver Plate $19.99 Time Remaining: 1h 20m |
 Skinless Frankfurters or Weiners Home Food Meat Lunch 1941 Antique Advertisement $5.99 Time Remaining: 29d 19h 18m Buy It Now for only: $5.99 Buy It Now |
 Antique Universal Meat Grinder Hand Crank Chopper Sausage Mincer Food Iron VGC $0.99 (1 Bid) Time Remaining: 1d 2h 43m |
 HUGE Antique Foster Bros Butchers Slaughterhouse Meat Cleaver Hog Splitter $349.99 Time Remaining: 26d 21h 6m Buy It Now for only: $349.99 Buy It Now |
 1885 ANTIQUE COOK BOOK The Every Day Cookery w Directions on CARVING MEAT $11.45 (3 Bids) Time Remaining: 3h 52m |
 HWPEACE 40 VINTAGE MEAT SAW $8.00 (1 Bid) Time Remaining: 7h 11m |
 Amours Star Meats Bacon Home Breakfast Food Recipes 1941 Antique Advertisement $5.99 Time Remaining: 29d 19h 16m Buy It Now for only: $5.99 Buy It Now |
 Antique Pattern Sterling Silver Serving Cold Meat Fork 9 Long Hallmarked $19.00 Time Remaining: 1d 17h 25m |
 Antique Vintage Primitive Meat Cleaver Hickory Wood Handle $29.00 Time Remaining: 19d 2h 45m Buy It Now for only: $29.00 Buy It Now |
 Antique Cast Iron Columbia Meat Juice Press LFC 3 pc $24.50 Time Remaining: 4h 4m |
 A 1917 ENTERPRISE MEAT FOOD GRINDER COOK KITCHEN CHOPPER $21.95 Time Remaining: 4h 22m |
 Antique IDEAL Wooden Handle Vintage 7 Meat Cleaver Butchers Knife Chopper $14.99 Time Remaining: 7h 47m Buy It Now for only: $14.99 Buy It Now |
 VINTAGE UNIVERSAL 3 FOOD MEAT CHOPPER SAUSAGE HAND GRINDER Original Complete $45.97 Time Remaining: 7h 40m |
 GORGEOUS Antique Samuel Lee 1886 Chefs 8 Carbon Steel Meat Cleaver RAZOR SHARP $144.05 Time Remaining: 13d 6h 56m Buy It Now for only: $144.05 Buy It Now |
 ANTIQUE GRISWOLD 2 FOOD MEAT CHOPPER GRINDER RARE NICE $16.99 Time Remaining: 4h 47m Buy It Now for only: $21.99 Buy It Now |
 FINE Antique Italian Chefs HEAVY DUTY Hand forged Meat Cleaver Butcher Knife $374.05 Time Remaining: 28d 8h 24m Buy It Now for only: $374.05 Buy It Now |
 ANTIQUE PRIMITIVE CLIMAX TABLE MEAT OR COFFEE GRINDER HAMILTON OHIO PAT PENDING $11.95 Time Remaining: 1h 59m |
 ANTIQUE BLUE WHITE MEAT PLATE OXBURGH HALL PATTERN A F $9.96 (3 Bids) Time Remaining: 1d 20h 33m |
 VINTAGE UNIVERSAL 2 TABLE MOUNT HAND OPERATED MEAT GRINDER EXCELLENT CONDITION $12.95 Time Remaining: 23d 5h Buy It Now for only: $12.95 Buy It Now |
 Antique Meat Weight Scale made in Michigan by the Standard Computing Scale Co $499.00 Time Remaining: 4h 29m Buy It Now for only: $695.00 Buy It Now |
 VINTAGE COLUMBIA 11 KITCHEN ANTIQUE MEAT GRINDER MADE IN USA $12.00 Time Remaining: 27d 21h 27m Buy It Now for only: $12.00 Buy It Now |
 Vintage Antique THorntons England Silver Meat Serving Set $0.99 (1 Bid) Time Remaining: 21h 5m |
 Antique Sterling Meat Craving Knife Fork $29.95 Time Remaining: 3h 24m |
 Vintage Silver Cast Iron Universal 2 Food Meat Grinder Chopper w 3 Blades $27.00 Time Remaining: 18d 9h 4m Buy It Now for only: $27.00 Buy It Now |
 BIG ANTIQUE BUTCHERS MEAT CLEAVER SLAUGHTERHOUSE TOOL EARLY OLD VTG ENGLAND $36.00 Time Remaining: 3d 23h 56m Buy It Now for only: $42.00 Buy It Now |
 VINTAGE UNIVERSAL 1 KITCHEN ANTIQUE MEAT GRINDER MADE IN USA $12.00 Time Remaining: 27d 21h 18m Buy It Now for only: $12.00 Buy It Now |
 HUGE Antique Chefs Butcher Knife Meat Cleaver Wallace No 9 Steel Blade Rare $99.00 Time Remaining: 5d 1h 10m Buy It Now for only: $149.00 Buy It Now |
 ANTIQUE 1800 S TOBACCO GRINDER MEAT SAUSAGE STUFFER IN WORKING ORDER EX NR $14.99 (1 Bid) Time Remaining: 7h 24m |
 Antique 19th C Chefs Butchers 8 Meat Cleaver NICHOLS BROS Greenfield Mass $125.00 Time Remaining: 15d 17m Buy It Now for only: $125.00 Buy It Now |
 LANDERS FRARY CLARK Vintage 1580 Food Chopper Meat Grinder in Original Box $18.00 Time Remaining: 1d 5h 14m |
 Vintage Hodges Sheffield England Antique Butcher Meat Carving Fork $24.99 Time Remaining: 16d 7h 39m Buy It Now for only: $24.99 Buy It Now |
 1886 antique DAISY SCRAP MACHINE+STAR MEAT CUTTER lettr $9.99 Time Remaining: 2h 30m |
 Oxo Good Grips Wooden Meat Tenderizer Sale Price: $6.99  Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionOXO Good Grips Wooden Utensils are made of solid beech wood with a natural oil finish. The Wooden Meat Tenderizer has one side to flatten and one side to tenderize. and features a large, comfortable handle.  |
 Executive Antique Truck Gourmet -Medium Sale Price: $62.99 See Reviews For This Product DescriptionFor the antique buff or the truck fanatic, this is the perfect gift for the man in your life. A beautiful solid wood antique truck carries a load of sweet and savory goodies that can be enjoyed at home or at the office... |
 Bloodrayne (Unrated Director's Cut) List Price: Sale Price: $6.09 You save: $3.86 (39%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionBLOODRAYNE - DVD Movie |
 Pointed Antique Cold Meat Fork List Price: Sale Price: $242.00 You save: $213.99 (47%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 4-5 business days See Reviews For This Product Description1159322700 The Pointed Antique collection debuted in 1895, and features a lightly brushed finish, giving it a more antique feel than most sterling silver flatware. An authentic reproduction of the original design by Paul Revere, this collection will enhance the elegance of any dinner table... |
 American Meat At Liverpool 1877 Antique Print Trade List Price: Sale Price: $21.75 You save: $16.00 (42%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionOld Antique Historical Victorian Prints Maps and Historic Fine Art----------. American Meat At Liverpool 1877 Antique Print Trade Page From An 1877 Issue Of . The Graphic An Illustrated Weekly Newspaper With Wood Engraving And Early Photographs ... |
 BBQ barbeque Meat Sign restaurant or Kitchen Decor Collectible Vintage Retro Thick Sturdy Plaque Sale Price: $11.85 See Reviews For This Product Description[J E MATRIX SIGNS AND DESIGNS] \\THIS IS THE PERFECT UNIQUE GIFT// \\MAKE A GREAT IMPRESSION WITH YOUR Friends or Customers// [this is an original design made exclusively for this sign and this store] ( SIZE 8 INCHES HIGH BY 10 INCHES WIDE ) ( 1/8TH INCH THICK ) ( MATERIAL_______HIGH QUALITY HARDBOARD WOOD VERY STURDY ) ( HANGING _______4 HOLES READY TO PIN ANYWHERE ) ... |
 Australian Meat Supper Newcastle C1872 Antique Print List Price: Sale Price: $16.75 You save: $8.24 (33%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days See Reviews For This Product DescriptionAustralian Meat Supper Newcastle C1872 Antique Print Old Antique Print . Part Page . From The Illustrated London News 1840-1902 . Or The Graphic. Size Of Full Page 15.5 X 11 Inches Part Page Prorata 1870-1900 ... |
 Advocate Men April 2006 (Rhodes Trip, Men of Swim Meat 2) See Reviews For This Product |
 Victorinox 12-Inch Granton Edge Slicing Knife with Fibrox Handle List Price: Sale Price: $39.95 You save: $28.65 (42%) Eligible for free shipping!Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours See Reviews For This Product DescriptionThe R H Forschner by Victorinox Slicing Knife features high carbon, stainless steel blade, hand finished at Victorinox in Switzerland by skilled craftsmen. A special tempering process is used to produce an edge that can be resharpened over and over again, so the knife can keep its original sharpness throughout the entire life of the blade... |
